Editorial assessment and peer review
All submissions are initially assessed by the editorial team for suitability, scope and compliance with the journal’s requirements. A manuscript may be declined at this stage without external peer review. The handling editor decides whether revised manuscripts require further external review.
Original research articles, case reports and review articles that proceed beyond initial assessment are evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise. The editor considers their reports and makes the final decision.
For other article types, such as editorials and image articles, the editor may decide that internal editorial review is sufficient. The editor may also seek external advice when the subject or content requires it.
The journal does not use peer reviews transferred from another journal. Reviewers must declare relevant conflicts of interest and treat manuscripts confidentially. The journal uses double-anonymised review for external peer review, with author and reviewer identities withheld from each other. Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential submission material to publicly accessible generative-AI systems or services where confidentiality cannot be assured. AI must not replace independent reviewer or editorial judgment.
Editors should be ready to justify any important deviation from the described process. Editors should not reverse decisions on publication unless serious problems are identified.
Editors should publish guidance for authors and reviewers explaining what is expected of them. The guidance should be updated regularly and refer or link to this code.
Further details are available under the link Editorial and Peer Review Process