Editorial & Peer Review Process

SJEMed, published by Discover STM Publishing Ltd and owned by Waraqa Evidence Ltd, assesses every submission editorially and then sends suitable manuscripts for double-anonymized (double-blind) external peer review. Original (research) articles, review articles and case reports that proceed beyond initial assessment are reviewed by at least two independent external reviewers. Other article types, such as letters to the editor, editorials and image articles, are reviewed according to their content, as set out in the Peer Review Policy. Conference and meeting abstracts are reviewed by the conference organizer and forwarded to SJEMed for publication only. Reviewers advise; the handling editor makes the final decision.

1. Submission of a manuscript

Authors submit manuscripts through the SJEMed online submission system, with the files and declarations listed in the Guide for Authors.

2. Administrative and Technical Check

The Editorial Office checks that all files, declarations and any required ethics or consent documents are present and that the manuscript is correctly formatted. The quality of the manuscript is not judged at this stage. Each manuscript is also screened for similarity to published work; a similarity report is a starting point for the editors and does not by itself show plagiarism.

3. Initial Editorial Assessment by the Editor-in-Chief

The Editor-in-Chief assesses whether the manuscript suits SJEMed, considering its scope, article type, originality, clinical or scientific value, reporting quality, methods and ethics. Manuscripts that are outside the scope, do not meet the requirements, or have serious methodological or ethical problems are declined at this stage without external review.

4. Handling Editor

After the Editor-in-Chief's initial appraisal, the manuscript is assigned to a handling editor (the Editor-in-Chief or a section editor), who manages peer review.

5. Selection of Independent Reviewers

For manuscripts that need external review, the handling editor invites reviewers with relevant expertise who are independent of the authors and have no competing interests, and sends further invitations until the required number of reviews is secured.

6. Reviewers Respond to Invitations

Invited reviewers accept only if they have the expertise and time to review the manuscript properly. They must declare any competing interests, keep the manuscript confidential, and decline if they cannot be impartial. When declining, they may suggest another reviewer.

7. Double-Anonymized (Double-Blind) External Peer Review

Authors do not know who the reviewers are, and reviewers are not told who the authors are. Manuscripts and reports are confidential. Reviewers assess the clinical or scientific value, methods, interpretation and reporting; point out strengths and weaknesses; raise any ethical concerns; and explain their recommendations. They must not upload any part of the manuscript, patient information or data to public AI tools, and they remain responsible for their own assessment.

8. Reviewer Recommendations and Editorial Evaluation

Reviewers recommend acceptance, revision (major or minor) or rejection and explain why. The handling editor considers the reports together with the manuscript, any ethical concerns and the journal's requirements; decisions are not made by counting votes. If the reports differ widely, the editor may ask for clarification or invite another reviewer.

9. Revised Manuscripts and Further Review

Authors asked to revise must submit the revised manuscript with a point-by-point response to the editors' and reviewers' comments, explaining any suggestions they have not followed. The editor decides whether the revision needs further external review.

10. Final Editorial Decision and Communication

The handling editor makes the final decision: accept, revise further or reject. The Editorial Office sends the decision to the corresponding author with the reviewers' and editor's comments. Confidential comments to the editor are not forwarded, and reviewers' identities are protected. Reviewers may be told the outcome. Accepted manuscripts then go to production.

You can read our Peer Review Policy here.

Editorial Independence and Research Integrity

Editorial decisions are independent of article processing charges, an author's ability to pay, advertising, sponsorship and any other commercial interest. Payment does not affect peer review or guarantee acceptance. The Saudi Red Crescent Authority, an affiliated society, has no role in editorial decisions.

Concerns about plagiarism, redundant publication, fabrication, falsification, image or data manipulation, authorship or undeclared interests are handled following the COPE flowcharts. The editors first ask the authors for an explanation. SJEMed does not carry out misconduct investigations itself; where an investigation is needed, the matter is referred to the authors' institution. Depending on the outcome, a manuscript may be rejected, or a published article may be corrected, given an expression of concern or retracted. A concern on its own does not lead to rejection.

Authors may ask for a decision to be reconsidered if they believe there was an error or that important information was overlooked, as described in the appeals procedure in the Editorial Policies. Reconsideration does not guarantee another round of peer review.

Related SJEMed policies: Peer Review Policy, Publishing Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement and Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern.

Last reviewed: November 2026. Policy responsibility: SJEMed Editorial Office, in accordance with the policies of the journal's owner, Waraqa Evidence Ltd, and its publisher, Discover STM Publishing Ltd.