Plagiarism Policy

SJEMed, published by Discover STM Publishing Ltd and owned by Waraqa Evidence Ltd, requires original work with proper credit to sources. The editors assess possible plagiarism, text reuse and redundant publication using similarity screening, their own judgment and COPE guidance.

What is Plagiarism?

Plagiarism is presenting another person's words, ideas, data, figures or images as one's own without acknowledging the source. It includes copying, close paraphrasing and using substantial material without credit; rewording does not remove the need to cite the source. Text that matches another source is not plagiarism if it is properly quoted and cited.

Types of Plagiarism

  • Direct plagiarism: copying someone else's work word for word without quotation marks or citation.
  • Text recycling (self-plagiarism): reusing one's own published wording without citing or disclosing it, especially where it hides duplicate findings.
  • Paraphrasing plagiarism: rewriting someone else's work in one's own words without citing it.
  • Mosaic plagiarism: combining phrases or ideas from several sources into new text without citing them.
  • Misuse of material: using another person's data, figures or images without acknowledgment.

Plagiarism and Copyright

Plagiarism is about failing to credit a source; copyright infringement is about using protected material without permission. One act can be both, and citing a source does not replace permission where permission is needed. Authors must cite their sources and obtain permission to reuse third-party material. Openly licensed material can be reused under the terms of its license. See SJEMed Copyright Information.

Text Recycling and Redundant Publication

When authors reuse their own earlier work, the editors look at how much is repeated and where, whether it is cited, what is new, and whether the methods, results or conclusions are repeated. Repeating a short standard description of methods is usually acceptable. Publishing the same findings again without disclosure is redundant publication.

Splitting one study into several thin papers ("salami publication") is not acceptable, although separate questions or substantial new analyses of the same dataset may be published if the earlier work is cited. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time is not allowed and leads to rejection. A disclosed preprint is not treated as duplicate submission.

Preprints and Prior Presentation

SJEMed accepts manuscripts posted on a recognized preprint server; a preprint does not count as prior publication. Authors must give the server and the DOI or link at submission and, after publication, update the preprint with a link to the article. Overlap with a disclosed preprint is not plagiarism. A preprint must not be described as peer reviewed, and the preprint rule does not cover an earlier journal article. See also the Publishing Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement.

A disclosed conference abstract, poster or presentation does not prevent publication of the full report; the editors consider what the full article adds. A translation or second publication in another language is considered only with the agreement of both journals' editors, clear citation of the original, and compliance with the ICMJE guidance on overlapping publications and copyright.

Overlapping Clinical Cases and Datasets

For case reports and case series, the editors check whether the same patient, findings, images, treatment, outcome or dataset have already been published. A patient or dataset may be reported again if the new article asks a different question or adds new follow-up or analysis and cites the earlier report. Publishing essentially the same case again as a new report without saying so is redundant publication.

Similarity Screening

The Editorial Office screens submissions with iThenticate*, with access provided through Discover STM Publishing Ltd, and may use other tools. A similarity report helps the editors decide; it does not prove plagiarism, guarantee originality or detect every problem.

Reading Similarity Reports

SJEMed does not judge plagiarism by an overall similarity percentage. The editors look at the matching sources, where and how the text overlaps, whether it is cited, the authors' disclosures and publication history, and the effect on originality. A low score does not prove there is no plagiarism, and a high score does not prove misconduct. References, cited quotations, standard terms, methods descriptions and disclosed preprints are judged in context.

Assessment and Editorial Action

Overlap may be found by screening, by a reviewer or by someone else who reports it. The editor reviews the sources, citations, disclosures and publication history and decides whether the issue is plagiarism, text recycling, redundant publication, a copyright problem or another integrity concern. In significant cases the authors are asked to explain and to provide sources, related publications or permissions.

Minor problems are fixed by adding citations, correcting quotations, rewording or revising the manuscript. Serious plagiarism or redundant publication leads to rejection. SJEMed does not carry out misconduct investigations itself; where an investigation is needed, the matter is referred to the authors' institution. A similarity result alone never leads to rejection or referral. Any ban on future submissions requires a separate, fair and documented procedure. Decisions are independent of article processing charges, and payment cannot make up for serious plagiarism. The editors follow the COPE guidance on plagiarism.

Concerns After Publication

Concerns raised after publication are handled under the Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern policy. Depending on the evidence, the outcome may be no action, a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction. Serious plagiarism or redundant publication may lead to retraction when it undermines the article as a whole; a single uncited passage usually does not. Retraction corrects the record and is not a punishment. See SJEMed Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern and Discover STM Corrections, Retractions and Misconduct.

Artificial Intelligence

AI tools cannot be authors. Authors are responsible for the originality of their work, accurate references, data and images, and must declare any use of AI. References suggested by AI must be checked, and invented references, patient histories, clinical data or images must never be presented as real. Text produced with AI that copies an identifiable source without citing it may be plagiarism. An AI-detection score alone does not prove plagiarism or misconduct. Falsified data, altered images and false ethics statements are serious problems even when the similarity score is low. See also the Publishing Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement.

Reporting Concerns

Anyone can report suspected plagiarism or duplicate publication to the SJEMed Editorial Office at contact@sjemed.com, giving the article or manuscript title, the matching source, where they overlap, a DOI, link or reference number (and the volume and issue if available), and any supporting information. People reporting a concern do not need to prove misconduct. Reviewers should raise concerns privately with the editor and should not accuse authors publicly or contact institutions themselves. The editors assess each report fairly and do not treat an unproven allegation as fact.

* iThenticate is the registered trademark of Turnitin.

Related guidance: SJEMed Editorial Policies, Guide for Authors and Peer Review Policy; Discover STM Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement (see also).

Last reviewed: November 2026. Policy responsibility: SJEMed Editorial Office, in accordance with the policies of the journal's owner, Waraqa Evidence Ltd, and its publisher, Discover STM Publishing Ltd.