The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study
Authors:
Yahia Akeely,
Mutaz Mousa Alharbi,
Swaid Raza Saulat,
Albaraa Mehdar,
Naif Misfer Alzhrany,
Fahad M Samarkandy,
Gary M Vilke,
Saleh Alesa
Background: Currently, the demand for emergency medicine physicians is much higher than the available workforce. To overcome this issue, some institutions have increased their working hours. No previous study in Saudi Arabia addresses this issue and its impacts on physicians. Aim of the study: this study evaluates physicians health, social life, and decision making in 12 hours shifts compared against regular 8 hours. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted in various cities and hospitals in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia using a questionnaire that surveyed 173 emergency physicians working in different hospitals across Saudi Arabia. Results: There were many similarities and differences between the participants who worked 12-hour shifts and those who worked 8-hour shifts. The most significant differences were that those who worked 12-hour shifts were more likely to be male than female and more likely to be married than unmarried. In addition, the 12-hour working physicians had more nonworking partners than the 8-hour group. Furthermore, they had less time for socialization with friends. Changes in blood sugar levels and headache were more common in the 12-hour group. Both groups had a similar incidence of COVID-19, physical illnesses, and the use of sedative medications. The two groups showed almost the same decision-making abilities. On the other hand, only 8.1% of those working 12-hour shifts wanted to continue working 12-hour shifts, and 69.1% in the 8-hour group wanted to continue working 8-hour shifts. Conclusion: Both 8- and 12-hour shifts appear feasible and safe.
Keywords: emergency physician, 12-hour shift, physician performance, shift's length, working hours.
Authors
Mutaz Mousa Alharbi
Department of Academic Affairs and Training, General Directorate of Health Affairs in Riyadh Region. Ministry of Health, Saudi Arabia
Google Scholor Articles
Pubmed Articles
Correspondence to:
Yahia Yaseen Akeely, Department of Emergency Medicine, Security Forces Hospital Kingdom of Saudi Arabia yahiaakeely@hotmail.com
Publication history:
Received 21 Apr 2021
Revised 15 Jul 2021
Accepted 22 Jul 2021
Published online 15 Aug 2021
Published in print 18 Oct 2021
Akeely Y, Alharbi MM, Saulat SR, Mehdar A, Alzhrany NM, Samarkandy FM, Vilke GM, Alesa S. The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. SJEMed. 2021; 2(3): 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely Y, Alharbi MM, Saulat SR, Mehdar A, Alzhrany NM, Samarkandy FM, Vilke GM, Alesa S. The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. https://sjemed.com/?mno=75353 [Access: November 23, 2024]. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely Y, Alharbi MM, Saulat SR, Mehdar A, Alzhrany NM, Samarkandy FM, Vilke GM, Alesa S. The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. SJEMed. 2021; 2(3): 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely Y, Alharbi MM, Saulat SR, Mehdar A, Alzhrany NM, Samarkandy FM, Vilke GM, Alesa S. The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. SJEMed. (2021), [cited November 23, 2024]; 2(3): 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely, Y., Alharbi, . M. M., Saulat, . S. R., Mehdar, . A., Alzhrany, . N. M., Samarkandy, . F. M., Vilke, . G. M. & Alesa, . S. (2021) The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. SJEMed, 2 (3), 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely, Yahia, Mutaz Mousa Alharbi, Swaid Raza Saulat, Albaraa Mehdar, Naif Misfer Alzhrany, Fahad M. Samarkandy, Gary M. Vilke, and Saleh Alesa. 2021. The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. Saudi Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2 (3), 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely, Yahia, Mutaz Mousa Alharbi, Swaid Raza Saulat, Albaraa Mehdar, Naif Misfer Alzhrany, Fahad M. Samarkandy, Gary M. Vilke, and Saleh Alesa. "The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study." Saudi Journal of Emergency Medicine 2 (2021), 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely, Yahia, Mutaz Mousa Alharbi, Swaid Raza Saulat, Albaraa Mehdar, Naif Misfer Alzhrany, Fahad M. Samarkandy, Gary M. Vilke, and Saleh Alesa. "The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study." Saudi Journal of Emergency Medicine 2.3 (2021), 244-249. Print. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175
Akeely, Y., Alharbi, . M. M., Saulat, . S. R., Mehdar, . A., Alzhrany, . N. M., Samarkandy, . F. M., Vilke, . G. M. & Alesa, . S. (2021) The impacts of working 12-hour shifts in the emergency Department on physicians' health, social life, and decision-making: a cross-sectional study. Saudi Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2 (3), 244-249. doi:
10.24911/SJEMed/72-1619037175